The necessity of historical inquiry in educational research: the case of Religious Education

publication-status: PublishedThis is an Author's Original Manuscript of an article whose final and definitive form, the Version of Record, has been published in the British Journal of Religious Education, July 2010. Available online at: http://www.tandfonline.com/ or DOI: 10.1080/01416200.2010.498612This article explores the mixed fortunes of historical inquiry as a method in educational studies and exposes evidence for the neglect of this method in religious education research in particular. It argues that historical inquiry, as a counterpart to other research methods, can add depth and range to our understanding of education, including religious education, and can illuminate important longer‐term, broader and philosophical issues. The article also argues that many historical voices have remained silent in the existing historiography of religious education because such historiography is too generalised and too biased towards the development of national policy and curriculum and pedagogical theory. To address this limitation in educational research, this article promotes rigorous historical studies that are more substantially grounded in the appropriate historiographical literature and utilise a wide range of original primary sources. Finally, the article explores a specific example of the way in which a historical approach may be fruitfully applied to a particular contemporary debate concerning the nature and purpose of religious education

The Williams Scale of Attitude toward Paganism: development and application among British Pagans

This article builds on the tradition of attitudinal measures of religiosity established by Leslie Francis and colleagues with the Francis Scale of Attitude toward Christianity (and reflected in the Sahin-Francis Scale of Attitude toward Islam, the Katz-Francis Scale of Attitude toward Judaism, and the Santosh-Francis Scale of Attitude toward Hinduism) by introducing a new measure to assess the attitudinal disposition of Pagans. A battery of items was completed by 75 members of a Pagan Summer Camp. These items were reduced to produce a 21-item scale that measured aspects of Paganism concerned with: the God/Goddess, worshipping, prayer, and coven. The scale recorded an alpha coefficient of 0.93. Construct validity of the Williams Scale of Attitude toward Paganism was demonstrated by the clear association with measures of participation in private rituals

Whole-genome sequencing reveals host factors underlying critical COVID-19

Critical COVID-19 is caused by immune-mediated inflammatory lung injury. Host genetic variation influences the development of illness requiring critical care1 or hospitalization2,3,4 after infection with SARS-CoV-2. The GenOMICC (Genetics of Mortality in Critical Care) study enables the comparison of genomes from individuals who are critically ill with those of population controls to find underlying disease mechanisms. Here we use whole-genome sequencing in 7,491 critically ill individuals compared with 48,400 controls to discover and replicate 23 independent variants that significantly predispose to critical COVID-19. We identify 16 new independent associations, including variants within genes that are involved in interferon signalling (IL10RB and PLSCR1), leucocyte differentiation (BCL11A) and blood-type antigen secretor status (FUT2). Using transcriptome-wide association and colocalization to infer the effect of gene expression on disease severity, we find evidence that implicates multiple genes—including reduced expression of a membrane flippase (ATP11A), and increased expression of a mucin (MUC1)—in critical disease. Mendelian randomization provides evidence in support of causal roles for myeloid cell adhesion molecules (SELE, ICAM5 and CD209) and the coagulation factor F8, all of which are potentially druggable targets. Our results are broadly consistent with a multi-component model of COVID-19 pathophysiology, in which at least two distinct mechanisms can predispose to life-threatening disease: failure to control viral replication; or an enhanced tendency towards pulmonary inflammation and intravascular coagulation. We show that comparison between cases of critical illness and population controls is highly efficient for the detection of therapeutically relevant mechanisms of disease

Paradoxical elevation in adiponectin concentrations in women with preeclampsia

Adiponectin is a recently identified, insulin-sensitizing and anti-inflammatory protein released by adipocytes, which is paradoxically reduced in obesity. It suppresses endothelial activation. Physiological insulin resistance occurs in normal pregnancy and is exaggerated in women with preeclampsia (PE), together with enhanced inflammatory and endothelial activation. Women with increased body mass index (BMI) and insulin resistance are predisposed to PE. We hypothesized that adiponectin concentrations are reduced in normal pregnancy compared with postpartum values and further reduced in women with PE. Fifteen women with PE and 30 control subjects with similar first trimester BMI had adiponectin concentrations measured in the third trimester; postpartum measurements were repeated in 16 control subjects. Adiponectin concentration in healthy pregnant women correlated inversely with early pregnancy BMI (r=−0.47, P=0.01) and fasting insulin concentrations (r=−0.58, P=0.001). However, adiponectin concentrations did not differ significantly in pregnancy and postpartum samples (mean change, −0.15 µg/mL; 95% CI, −2.28 to 1.98, P=0.88). Plasma adiponectin concentrations were markedly elevated (P=0.01) in women with PE (mean, 21.6; SD, 8.18 µg/mL) compared with control subjects (mean, 14.7; SD, 7.06 µg/mL). Moreover, in PE, adiponectin concentrations did not correlate with first trimester BMI or insulin or with serum urate or creatinine concentrations or urinary protein levels. We conclude that plasma adiponectin concentrations are not elevated in normal human pregnancy and paradoxically elevated (by 47%) in women with PE. This may be secondary to exaggerated nonspecific adipocyte lipolysis or as a physiological response to enhance fat utilization and attenuate endothelial damage. Future studies should determine whether adiponectin concentrations help improve prediction of PE